On Thursday, November 19, 2026, Susan Smith faced the South Carolina Board of Paroles and Pardons for her second shot at parole. Her bid was unsuccessful and she remains in prison for the murder of her two sons, Michael, 3, and Alex, aged 14 months.
Comparing Clancy And Smith
Ahead of the latest parole hearing, people on social media compared Susan Smith to Lindsay Clancy, who also killed her young children, Cora, Dawson, and Callan.
Back in September, Tommy Pope, the former prosecutor who handled the Susan Smith case, spoke with Fox News to compare Smith’s trial with that of Lindsay Clancy.
Mental Health Issues
At first glance, both cases involve mothers who killed their young children while claiming severe mental health struggles.
However, Pope noted that the parallels ended there.
In Smith’s trial, the defense’s psychiatrist, Seymour Halleck, testified that while she was suicidal and depressed, she was neither insane nor psychotic at the time of the murders.
Unlike in Clancy’s trial, Smith’s criminal responsibility was not the central issue the prosecution had to overcome.
Clancy’s Defense And Criminal Responsibility
On the other hand, Lindsay Clancy’s case went in the opposite direction. Her psychiatric state at the time of the killings is central to the defense’s approach.
Once the issue of criminal responsibility was raised, the prosecution bore the burden of proving beyond a reasonable doubt that Clancy was criminally responsible for her actions.
The Husbands
With Susan Smith, her husband David wanted his former wife prosecuted. In her first parole hearing in 2024 and again this week, he was not calling for her release.
Biography.com noted that he said, “She took away one of the greatest gifts God gives us: life. She did that deliberately. It wasn’t an accident, it wasn’t a mistake.”
Patrick Clancy, also a bereaved father, was called as a prosecution witness. But in a way, he also helped the defense because he said that despite her suicidal thoughts and mental health struggles, he didn’t believe or suspect she would kill the children.
Susan Has Served Time
CNN reminds readers that Susan Smith has served 31 years in prison for the murder of her children. Meanwhile, Lindsay Clancy very nearly had a jury unanimously find that she was not criminally responsible.
Except for one holdout juror, the case might never have come to retrial. Lindsay Clancy will be tried again in March next year. Meanwhile, Susan Smith can only have another parole hearing in 2028.
Per Fox News, David wants his wife to never see freedom again. Things went his way when the South Carolina parole board denied her freedom.
Other Differences
Smith’s defense maintained that she had planned to die with her sons in 1994, but changed her mind at the last moment and let the car roll into the lake without her.
Lindsay Clancy did attempt suicide and that’s why true crime followers see her in a wheelchair in court.
Your thoughts? Join the discussion and then come back for more true crime news and updates. We also have a crime channel on TikTok that you can follow.