X

Micah Smith Case: Could A Plea Deal Avoid Child Torture Trial?

Facebook via On The Case YouTube

Micah Smith from South Jordan, Utah, is getting a lot of attention because he allegedly placed the lives of his three children at risk while on a hiking trip in the mountains.

The October 2025 Hike

On Tuesday, Chris Stewart from On The Case for Law&Crime Network recapped what happened. People magazine had covered what went down in October last year when “he and his three children got caught in a storm on a hike in Utah’s Big Cottonwood Canyon.”

The kids were aged eight, four, and just two. Stewart said in his recap, “Look, there are some 2-year-olds who can barely walk. And prosecutors say in October of 2025, a toddler that age with their 8-year-old sister and four-year-old brother had to walk miles through tough terrain on what their dad called a hike.”

Tough Terrain

On top of that tough terrain, they had to deal with bad weather that came in. Then they got lost. They were off the trail. On top of that, their dad, Micah Smith, allegedly left his kids to go find help.

Part of the indicment shared by Law&Crime Network

They had been hoping to reach the summit of Twin Peaks via the Broads Fork Trail in Big Cottonwood Canyon. That translated into about nine miles with a lot of elevation gain, and it’s classified as a hard route.

Determined Not To Turn Back

Testimony from the 8-year-old girl provided to investigators included several troubling details. When she proposed that the group turn back, Smith reportedly shook his head and remarked, “This is a once-in-a-lifetime thing.” When she expressed fear, he allegedly responded, “You shall not pass.”

The Salt Lake Tribune reported that Micah Smith was hailed as a hero after “the county’s search and rescue team launched a search.”

It involved helicopters, and the four were rescued and transported to a hospital.

The Injuries

The two-year-old had fallen and struck his head and needed CPR. The daughter was shown how to do CPR to help keep him alive. Meanwhile, the four-year-old child struggled with hypothermia and stopped breathing.

They survived the night by taking shelter under a rock, and it seems that they might not have survived without the actions initiated in the search.

The Charges

Later, charges were brought against Micah Smith. Apart from taking the kids into a scary weather situation, he’d also reportedly entered Primary Children’s Hospital without authorization while Ezra was receiving treatment.

Allegedly, he disrupted the boy’s medical care and interfered with equipment. Authorities charged him with domestic violence in the presence of a child and interference with a communication device.

On November 26, 2025, Smith was indicted on six first-degree felony counts, each punishable by up to life imprisonment: three counts of child torture and three counts of aggravated child abuse.

The indictment characterizes Smith as “selfish” and asserts that he “chose to summit a mountain over the safety of the kids.”

Denied Bail

Prior to the start of the pre-trial hearings, Smith had been denied bail because the judge felt he was a “safety risk.”

Part of that stemmed from the fact that despite the weather coming in, Micah Smith seemed determined to complete the hike before returning to safety.

People cited Fox 13 as saying that he didn’t seem very concerned about the kids.

Phone video repeatedly showed them off the main trail while the children were cold and afraid. Nevertheless, Stewart said, “The prosecutor makes it seem like there could be a plea deal in place to avoid a trial.”

A Possible Plea Deal

During the pre-trial hearing this week, “he flashed what seemed to be a peace sign to someone in the gallery.”

There’s a motion cutoff date of December 11, and if the case goes to trial, it is set to start on January 26th.

Your thoughts? Join the discussion and then come back for all your true crime news and updates.

Categories: In The News
JJ Flowers: With over two decades of writing and editing experience since 2001, I enjoy bringing an investigative lens to storytelling and visual journalism. My early career was in the fields of law enforcement, prosecution, and a security background that helps my analytical approach, attention to detail, and passion for investigative reporting. As a media professional, my expertise bridges multiple creative disciplines. I am a freelance journalist, a self-published author, and a licensed professional photographer. To complement my practical field experience, I studied line management, human communications, and travel writing and photography.
Related Post