Lindsay Clancy Retrial Set As Prosecutors Reveal Their Hand
Tension surfaced in court as prosecutors signaled plans to pursue first-degree murder charges against Lindsay Clancy in a new trial set for March.
- 0Facebook
- 0Twitter
- 0Pinterest
- 0LinkedIn
- Total0

Lindsay Clancy pretrial hearings brought a bit of surprise on Monday this week because it became clear that she will face another trial on first-degree murder charges and it’s going to happen early next year. The court hearing came with some tension between the prosecution and the defense.
An Unorthodox Surprise
Elizabeth Vargas covered the news on NewsNation, and she said that prosecutors tried to “dance around” their plans during the hearing
But the intention to retry the mom who killed her three children, Cora, Dawson, and Callan, in January 2023 only became clear when an assistant district attorney told the court that the state was “ready to pick a jury trial date.”
Defense attorney Kevin Reddington caught on to that immediately. He quoted Julius Caesar inside the courthouse, telling Judge Sullivan that “the die has been cast.”

Lindsay Clancy’s defense lawyer added, “When the state says a case will require a jury, it’s an indirect comment from the DA that they intend to proceed on first-degree murder indictments.”
Some Tension In Court
The prosecution wanted to push the trial back until May, according to Elizabeth, who spoke with senior journalist Brian Entin. Judge William Sullivan didn’t want to wait that long, and in Brian’s opinion, it seems that he wants to finish what he started before his retirement in June.
When the two sides put forward their ideas on the trial date, there was again a bit of tension when the words of Julius Caesar were referred to. The words “the Ides of March” got the prosecutor snapping back with, “Sorry, I don’t have any jokes.”
Judge Sullivan settled the argument by scheduling March 29 for the new trial. It will put Lindsay Clancy back in the spotlight in the debate over competency and postpartum mental health. Remember, the first trial ended with one juror holding out, so a retrial was ordered.
Commenting On The DA
Kevin Reddington seemed irritated because he hadn’t gotten any warning from the District Attorney’s office to clarify a retrial had been decided on.
Contrary to speculation, it also sounds like there weren’t any plea talks happening behind the scenes either.
Reddington seemed frustrated outside the courthouse in Plymouth, and when reporters questioned him about the DA’s plans, he told the press to “drive over to Main Street, walk into his office and ask him.”
He also admitted that it was going to be difficult for the family, for his client, Lindsay, and for the future jurors.
Selecting an unbiased jury in Plymouth might not be easy given the amount of publicity, so the two crime reporters on NewsNation wondered if Reddington might ask for the jury to be sequestered this time around.
Viewers React
In the comments of the video on YouTube, true crime viewers weighed in with their thoughts. The case has been contentious since the beginning because many people felt postpartum issues had been swept under the rug.
Meanwhile, other folks want accountability for the deaths of the three children.
One viewer wrote, “USA are using outdated practices and guidelines in postpartum assessments. European guidelines are and understanding are advanced.”
Here are a few more responses from the discussion:
- “JUSTICE FOR THE BABIES”
- “Taxpayers had enough of their money being wasted on this person.”
- “I want her convicted.”
- “Life in prison”
Your thoughts? Join the discussion and then come back here for all your true crime news and updates. We also have a crime channel on TikTok that you can follow.