Bryan Kohberger agreed to plead guilty in July 2025 to the 2022 murders of four University of Idaho students, and most people thought that the case was concluded. By pleading guilty, he got consecutive life terms instead of a possible death penalty.
A New Petition
Per The New York Times, Bryan Kohberger “said he had filed a petition challenging his conviction, citing concerns about how the plea deal came together.”
CNN cited Samuel Newton, an associate professor of law at the University of Idaho College of Law, who told the outlet, “Idaho Rule of Criminal Procedure 33(c) uses a lenient ‘fair and just reason’ standard before sentencing. But withdrawing can only be allowed to correct a ‘manifest injustice.'”
A Claim of Innocence
Kohberger claims he never committed the crimes and in an interview published by The New York Times, he insisted, “My actual innocence is my truth, and the plea, hinged on by false promises and blatant disinformation, MUST be withdrawn.”
Why Did He Petition?
Asked why he broke his silence, he responded by saying, “A lot went wrong in those plea discussions. I really do want to be heard.”
Kohberger argues that spending the rest of his life in prison for crimes he says he did not commit leaves him with little to lose.
The Victims’ Familes React
NBC News reported that Kohberger’s victims are not worried about a new trial.
The outlet cited them as saying, “He wants another chance to roll the dice… get another day in court… a welcome break from solitary confinement.” They also suggested he’s like “the mosquito you just can’t swat.”
An Expert Weights In
Today reported that NBC News legal expert Misty Marris explained that “there would have to be some really black-and-white evidence of misconduct, coercion, something that happened behind the scenes.”
And it should be noted that Bryan Kohberger isn’t hiring new lawyers. In fact, he’s representing himself.
NBC Montana Report
NBC Montana took a closer look at what’s going on and covered Bryan Kohberger’s statements to The New York Times regarding his petition. You can watch it below.
In the comments section, crime followers suggested that Bryan’s getting incorrect information from other prisoners. And others think he might really just be hoping to change the routines of prison life.
One person wrote, “He just wants the attention. Hell no. Let him sit in his cell in isolation.”
Another commenter echoed many others by saying, “That ineffective counsel got the death penalty off of your back.”
Your thoughts? Join the discussion and come back here often for more true crime news and updates, and remember we have a crime channel on TikTok that you can follow.