‘The Young and The Restless’ Poll: Who Was The Best Adam Newman – Justin Hartley or Michael Muhney? VOTE!

'The Young and The Restless' Poll: Who Was The Best Adam Newman - Justin Hartley or Michael Muhney? VOTE!For some fiercely loyal fans of ‘The Young and the Restless’, this poll is blasphemy. For others, it’s purely a hoot. So, as Justin Hartley enters a period that could spell the end of his daytime run, it’s fair to ask a question. Who was the best Adam Newman, Hartley or Michael Muhney?

Muhney burst onto the scene at ‘The Young and the Restless’ in 2009. He quickly turned a role that Chris Engen held for approximately a year (2008-2009), into prime daytime viewing. His interplay with Eric Braeden (Victor), in particular, was unlike any foil the great man faced before or since. Jack’s battles with the ‘Moustache’ were legendary. But, this was Victor, Junior, the man’s own son, who was verbally jabbing at “Pops”. And, elements within those scripts surely seemed to be ad-libbed consistently.

Behind-the-scenes battles between both actors were never fully confirmed. After his unexpected departure in 2014, Muhney admitted that his own ego had likely been his undoing. However, like any genius, reckless behavior is purely one vehicle through which greatness flows. Such talent doesn’t excuse all behavior, but does help to explain it. Anything is possible in Hollywood land. So, dismissing the chance that Muhney could reprise his role on Y&R wouldn’t seem wise.

Fans of The Young and the Restless waited for every instance, especially those shown in his later years, to see how Muhney’s version of Adam would take control of most scenes. His electric efforts clearly raised the game of each actor he appeared with. While still unconfirmed rumors regarding Muhney did affect the perceptions of some viewers, wide swaths of the audience place him with the best actors who ever plied their trade on this iconic steamer.

Soap opera fans commit to year-round viewing schedules for a reason. They love this brand of escapist entertainment. When ‘The Young and the Restless’ recast the role Muhney owned, viewers wondered it they’d be able to root for a new Adam. Y&R deserves full credit for choosing an actor who delivered.

Creating his own mood, Hartley proved to be one of the better replacements in recent daytime history. He wisely chose not to attempt a leap over the high bar Muhney crossed with ease. Instead, Hartley offered a more nuanced, less frenetic, element within Adam to a discerning audience.

How long, of if, Hartley remains on Y&R is unknown due to factors involving his new NBC show ‘This Is Us’. If Hartley does exit, fans won’t simply compare his replacement to Muhney. Instead, the work of both men will have established expectations. Considering that Hartley has been employed for less than half the time Muhney was, that expected assessment will reflect high praise.

Fans of ‘The Young and the Restless’ rightfully express their opinions on a regular basis. So, who played Adam Newman better, Justin Hartley or Michael Muhney? Vote in our poll below!

Soap Opera Spy is a leading source for everything linked to ‘The Young and the Restless’.

Share your thoughts in the Comments section below, on our Facebook Page,  join our Facebook Group or Head over to our Discussion Board to Talk Soaps Daily!

You might also likeMore from author


  1. Eyes Have It says

    Justin is a kinder, gentler Adam. But no one will replace Michael Muhney. Ever!!

  2. Aisha Renwick says

    Absolutely love Michael….he’s so amazing

  3. Darlene says

    Michael Muhney is by far the better actor of the two. it appears that many fans liked Justin and were pleased by his presentation of Adam Newman. it’s curious why Justin chose to leave the soap with less than 2 years on screen. Actually, Justin left Y&R several months ago by seeming to be focused on his new show This is Us and being actively involved in promoting his new show. It appears that something didn’t work for him at Y&R or he decided to return to prime time which pays better and is less work. or both.
    Nevertheless, please bring Michael Muhney back as Adam Newman. His portrayal of Adam was spell binding. Y&R needs the role recast as many fans only watch to see Adam, Chelsea and Connor. This little family is loved by fans and that was also true when Michael Muhney was in the role.

  4. Colleen says

    Justin reinvented Adam Newman. He made Adam more compassionate, forgiving, empathetic. These are qualities that were new for Adam. When I think of “bad ass” Adam, I think of Michael Muhney. Both are fantastic but they added their own flare to Adam.

    1. DianneP says

      This is exactly why Muhney is the right Adam. His Adam was complex and far more interesting. I doubt a white washed Adam is that appealing in Y&R fantasy land.

  5. vfocused says

    I think both did a great job. Micheal played a more ruthless Adam. Justin looked better. Justin was too good looking to be a Victor Jr. with all the bad guy stuff. If I had to choose it would be Micheal though. We just never got to see Micheal be the nice “Adam”. Both are still brilliant. I wish both the best but I wish they could bring Micheal back.

  6. Alysha Jones says

    Obviously Michael Muhney… He’s the only Adam!!!

  7. Dee says

    Michael is all facets of Adam & wasn’t afraid of digging his acting abilities into a controversial s/l made the last actor quit! He is and always will be Adam Newman. Justin was the only actor who could fill Adam’s shoes when all was lost with the fans. Bringing back Michael would put the show back on track, especially with the new regime!

  8. 12Feliciene says

    I really Iike them both & would love to see Michael return.

Leave A Reply

GT server