‘American Idol’ Fans Divided Over Judge’s Possible Conflict Of Interest

As American Idol inches closer to its grand finale, tensions are rising—not just among contestants but also within the show’s ever-passionate fanbase.

With only a few episodes left before the winner is revealed on May 18, the spotlight has expanded beyond the performances and into a swirl of speculation. At the heart of the latest debate? One contestant’s connection to a former band member of a current judge.

From Auditions to Allegations

Mattie Pruitt, one of the standout names in this season’s Top 7, has been catching attention for more than just her vocal prowess. During her audition, she was joined on stage by Craig Campbell, a country artist who, years ago, played in Luke Bryan’s band.

The moment, perhaps intended to be a show of support or simply an opportunity to create a memorable audition, has now sparked conversations about fairness and favoritism.

Fans have been vocal, and not everyone sees eye to eye.

“I’m from their town… can’t stand Craig,” one viewer bluntly shared online. “While I didn’t like that he was at the audition, I feel like she would’ve made it to Hollywood regardless. Now making it past that, I’m not sure.”

The critique isn’t without a counterbalance. Another viewer chimed in with a dose of realism:

“My point is, knowing someone or being related to someone or having an ‘in’ doesn’t necessarily mean you’re gonna go far in a talent competition. It’s not a conspiracy like so many people think regarding nepo babies and the like…”

And then there’s the practical view:

“I really don’t think it’s a big deal… Craig can’t even get his own songs on the radio, so this really isn’t the flex you might think.”

Is It Really a Big Deal?

At its core, the controversy raises a familiar question for reality competitions: where’s the line between support and influence?

While Craig Campbell’s presence certainly raised eyebrows, there’s no definitive proof that his past association with Luke Bryan had any measurable effect on Mattie’s advancement.

Still, in a competition where perception is everything and social media often shapes public opinion, even a hint of favoritism can snowball.

Some fans are calling for more transparency in how auditions and decisions are made, while others shrug it off as just another moment in a show that blends talent with television.

Top 7 and Tensions Rising

As the countdown to the finale continues, contestants like Slater Nalley, John Foster, and Jamal Roberts are all putting everything on the line.

But Mattie, despite the whispers around her journey, remains firmly in the mix—proving that whether or not her audition sparked controversy, her talent continues to carry her forward.

In the end, American Idol has always walked a tightrope between showbiz spectacle and genuine talent discovery. This latest debate? Just another reminder that in the world of reality TV, the drama doesn’t always end when the music stops.

Be sure to catch up on everything happening on American Idol right now. Come back here often for all American Idol’s spoilers, news, and updates.