Christa Pike Execution Looms As Supreme Court Weighs Last-Minute Appeal

We reported on Christa Pike earlier in January, noting that she had only 270 sleeps left before her scheduled execution on September 30, 2026. Now, the clock has almost run out.

The Crime

Christa Pike was found guilty of the murder of her 19-year-old classmate, Colleen Slemmer, that happened at the Knoxville Job Corps campus in January 1995.

Victim and Verdict explained the death of Slemmer, noting: “18-year-old Christa Pike, struggling with jealousy and insecurity, spent most of her time with her boyfriend, Tadaryl Shipp, a quiet 17-year-old who was deeply influenced by her.”

Shadolla Peterson, a friend, joined them as they lured Slemmer into a wooded area near campus, where witness testimony and forensic evidence revealed Colleen was brutally beaten.

Slemmer was also stabbed and taunted, and a pentagram was carved into her chest. Pike then beat Slemmer’s head with a chunk of asphalt, killing her, and kept a piece of her skull as a trophy.

The Supreme Court

With her execution imminent, NBC News carried an update on YouTube this week and reported that her case is pushing the U.S. Supreme Court into uncharted territory.

Lawyers for Christa Pike are asking the high court for a stay of execution. In the video, the outlet revealed that her legal team is raising a question the court has never answered before:

Does psychological terror caused by the process of lethal injection rise to cruel and unusual punishment?

In her petition, her attorneys argue that because her childhood abuse involved “being physically overpowered and immobilized by men,” putting her in straps for lethal injection creates “a near-perfect replication of the sensory conditions of her rapes.”

Tennessee courts previously rejected her claims, and state prosecutors urged the Supreme Court to deny her request, calling her legal argument “meritless.”

A History of Trauma

On the advocacy website, mercyforchrista.org, her support team outlines that Christa was born with “organic brain damage” and suffered “an almost unbearably abusive background.”

They claim that she experienced severe sexual violence starting when she was a toddler.

Evaluating psychologist Dr. Bethany Brand testified in court that Pike was likely dissociating during the 1995 murder of 19-year-old Colleen Slemmer.

Dr. Brand explained that Pike felt like she was “floating above the scene” and “looking down on herself and Colleen.”

Reports by the BBC highlight that her defense team believes “she’s too damaged for death row,” arguing her youth and severe mental health issues should have mitigated her sentence decades ago.

Despite those efforts, she remains on track to be the first woman executed in Tennessee in more than 200 years.

Not Afraid to Die

May Martinez, the mother of Colleen Slemmer, said she plans to sit in the witness room with a photograph of her daughter against the glass so it is the last thing Pike sees.

Pike is still hoping for a last-minute stay of execution, but she claims she’s ready, and the news outlet said that she wrote, “I am not afraid to die I am only nervous about the process.”

Viewers React

Commenters on the video offered little sympathy for the condemned killer.

One person wrote, “Why do cold blooded murderers feel they’re entitled to an ounce of mercy???????”

Here are a few more responses from the discussion:

• “She’s nervous about the process?! What about all of the things that Colleen felt while she was being tragically tortured and murdered?! I’m sure Colleen felt SCARED, PAIN, NAUSEOUS, HELPLESS and she’s nervous?? Yeah okay”
• “How about the psychological terror that her victims mother will be subjected to until she dies?”
• “She has lived 30+ more years than the girl she killed..I am sorry, but her Victim cannot come back and ask for better.”
• “Don’t do the crime if you can not face the consequences. She killed that poor girl for nothing.”

Your thoughts? Join the discussion and then come back for more true crime news and updates. You can also follow our crime channel on TikTok.