Tom Bergeron Comeback? Producer’s Surprising Response Sparks Buzz

For years, Dancing With the Stars fans have carried a soft spot for Tom Bergeron. His presence defined the show’s golden era, and when he briefly reappeared as a guest judge during the 20th birthday celebration episode, it reignited a wave of nostalgia.

Viewers instantly began asking the same question: Could this be the beginning of a full-time comeback? As it turns out, the answer isn’t what longtime fans were hoping for.

The Magic of Guest Judges—and Why Tom’s Appearance Hit Different

DWTS viewers have always had a mixed but mostly enthusiastic relationship with guest judges.

They shake up the energy, sometimes bring unexpected insight, and other times—like Flavor Flav’s now-infamous scoring slip involving Alix Earle—accidentally disrupt the leaderboard. Still, it keeps the show unpredictable.

But Tom’s return wasn’t just a “guest judge moment.” It felt like watching a foundational piece of the show snap back into place.

His trademark candor, warmth, and quick wit reminded fans exactly why they’d missed him. Suddenly, the calls for his reinstatement grew louder than ever.

What the Executive Producer Revealed

Hopes were high—until an executive producer addressed the speculation head-on, delivering an answer that was as firm as it was surprising.

The producer explained:

“We’ve evolved. Tom is part of our family, obviously…. I don’t ever see [us] bringing him back in that role, because now that’s Alfonso [Ribeiro]’s role, and I don’t think Tom would do that either. Maybe there’s something, who knows what it is.”

The response landed hard. Fans adore Alfonso Ribeiro, and many appreciate what he brings to the modern DWTS era. But still, the idea of Tom returning as host was a sentimental dream for many. Hearing that the door is effectively closed—at least for hosting duties—wasn’t easy.

Where Things Stand Now

While the producer made it clear that Bergeron won’t be stepping back into the hosting spotlight, the sentiment around him remains deeply affectionate.

Alfonso’s place is secure, and by all indications, respected by both fans and Tom himself. The role belongs to him now.

But none of this changes what Bergeron represents to longtime viewers. Even if he never resumes a permanent role, his legacy is woven into the show’s DNA. And as the producer hinted, there may still be room for him in other capacities—if the right idea comes along.

For fans, that tiny possibility might be enough to keep the hope alive.

Be sure to catch up on everything happening on DWTS now. Come back here often for all DWTS spoilers, news, and updates.